SW_WH1793_Page_317

in their opinions of the superior efficacy of this plan,that it is in vain to urge to them that it is cruel andimpolitic. The projectors of this plan, are my par-ticular friends, of the first rank and respectability inthe city of Philadelphia. I have no doubt but theexperience of one year will convince them of theirerror. I cannot be reconciled to think myself deservingthy very handsome compliment, in attributing to mehaving an important share in the establishment ofthe reformatory system in this country; the chiefcredit is due that truly wise and good man, WilliamPenn, whose example and hints relating to thisgreat subject, was acted on and improved by a num-ber of my valuable friends in Philadelphia, soon afterPennsylvania was declared an independent state. I have been very much gratified with thy commu-nications, and most particularly by the several pub-lications on the subject of penal jurisprudence, andI do beg, thou wilt be so kind as to favour me, occa-sionally, with some account of the progress made inthe reformatory system in England, and if any thingis doing relating to it, on the continent. I remain, yours, &;c. THOMAS EDDY.To WILLIAM ROSCOE, ESQ. Albany, 31st December, 1825. DEAR SIR, I have received your letter of the 27th. Every timeI visit Buffalo, I am fully convinced that the conti-guity of our settlements is destructive to the frac-tional or remnant population of the red men, andthat therefore their only salvation lies in removal toa distance. I have, however, never authorized anycommunication through Captain Parrish, or any otheragent, on that point. My rule has been to leave themto their own volitions.